The best pizza in Orlando, according to our readers

We asked our readers to tell us their favorite Orlando pizza parlor. Here’s what they said.

Orlando is a city known for its vibrant theme parks, bustling nightlife, and food that’s as exciting as the city itself. Among the culinary options, one category always garners a special kind of attention: pizza. The competition is fierce, but according to a recent readers’ poll survey, one establishment stands out as the best pizza in Orlando hands-down: Stone Fired.

Interestingly, we reported on a list from Stacker of Orlando’s best pies earlier this year, and Stone Fired didn’t make the cut. Clearly, our readers disagree. Join us as we delve into what makes Stone Fired the best pizza shop in Orlando, exploring its history, menu, atmosphere, and the secrets behind its crowd-pleasing pies.

Getty Images

From the outset, Stone Fired set itself apart by sticking to traditional methods. The dough recipe involves a meticulous 3-day fermentation process. This slow fermentation not only enhances the flavor but also creates a crust that’s light, airy, and perfectly crisp. Their stone oven, imported from Italy, reaches temperatures upwards of 900 degrees Fahrenheit, ensuring each pizza emerges with a beautifully charred crust and a smoky flavor that’s impossible to replicate in a conventional oven.

What truly sets Stone Fired apart is its menu, which marries tradition with innovation. Each pizza is a masterpiece, crafted with a combination of premium ingredients and culinary flair.

Stone Fired pays homage to the timeless classics that have defined pizza for generations. The Margherita, a staple of any pizzeria worth its salt, is a thing of beauty here. It features San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil, all resting on that signature crust. The balance of flavors is impeccable, making it clear why this simple yet elegant pie remains a favorite.

For those who appreciate a bit more complexity, the Pepperoni and Sausage pizza is a must-try. Loaded with house-made sausage, spicy pepperoni, and a generous sprinkling of fennel seeds, it offers a burst of flavors that dance on the palate.

While Stone Fired excels at the classics, it’s their innovative pizzas that often steal the show. The Truffle Shuffle, for example, is a decadent creation featuring wild mushrooms, truffle oil, fontina cheese, and a hint of rosemary. It’s a slice of luxury that leaves you craving more.

Another standout is the Green Monster, a vegetarian delight that combines pesto, arugula, artichokes, and goat cheese. This pizza is not only visually stunning but also a testament to how exciting vegetarian options can be.

Getty Images Signature

A great pizza deserves a great drink, and Stone Fired doesn’t disappoint in this regard. Their drink menu is carefully curated to complement the flavors of their pies. From a selection of craft beers, both local and international, to an impressive wine list that features everything from robust reds to crisp whites, there’s something for every palate. For those who prefer non-alcoholic options, their house-made sodas and lemonades are a refreshing treat.

So, what is it that makes Stone Fired the best pizza shop in Orlando, according to the readers’ poll survey? It’s a combination of several factors, each contributing to the overall excellence that sets this pizzeria apart.

In a city brimming with culinary delights, being named the best pizza shop in Orlando is no small feat. Stone Fired has earned this title through a combination of quality ingredients, expert craftsmanship, innovative menu offerings, and a deep connection to the community. Whether you’re a pizza purist who craves the classics or an adventurous eater looking for something new, Stone Fired offers a pizza experience that’s second to none.

So, next time you find yourself in Orlando with a craving for pizza, make your way to Stone Fired. Sit back, relax, and savor a slice (or three) of the best pie the city has to offer. And don’t forget to raise a glass of craft beer or a crisp white wine in a toast to the best pizza in Orlando.

STATEWIDE LIST: The best pizzas across Florida