The best ice cream shop in Orlando, according to our readers

We asked our readers to tell us their favorite Orlando ice cream shop. Here’s what they said.

When the scorching Florida sun has you craving a cool, sweet escape, Orlando locals know there’s only one place to go: Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream. According to a recent readers’ poll, Kelly’s has been crowned the best ice cream shop in Orlando, and it’s not hard to see why. From its delightful flavors to its community-centric approach, Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream has scooped its way into the hearts of many. Let’s dive into what makes this charming ice cream haven the top choice for sweet treats in the City Beautiful.

Pixabay

The story of Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream is one of passion and perseverance. Kelly and Scott Seidl, the masterminds behind this ice cream sensation, turned their dream into reality in 2015. What started as a small operation out of their home kitchen quickly blossomed into a beloved local institution. Their mission? To create the finest homemade ice cream using fresh, high-quality ingredients. And boy, have they succeeded!

One of the standout features of Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream is its extensive and inventive flavor menu. With over 20 flavors on rotation, there’s something to satisfy every palate. Whether you’re a fan of classic vanilla or adventurous enough to try flavors like Maple Bacon Bourbon, Kelly’s has you covered.

Let’s start with the classics. Kelly’s takes beloved flavors and elevates them to new heights. Their vanilla ice cream is anything but plain — it’s rich, creamy, and speckled with real vanilla beans. Chocolate lovers will rejoice at the decadent depth of their chocolate ice cream, made with the finest cocoa.

For those looking to step outside their comfort zone, Kelly’s offers a variety of unique flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. The Maple Bacon Bourbon, for instance, combines the smoky, savory taste of bacon with the sweetness of maple and a hint of bourbon. It’s a breakfast lover’s dream come true in ice cream form. Another fan favorite is the Lemon Poppy Seed, a refreshing and zesty delight that’s perfect for a hot day. The tangy lemon base, combined with the subtle crunch of poppy seeds, creates a symphony of flavors that dance on your tongue.

What sets Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream apart from the competition is their commitment to quality. Every batch of ice cream is made from scratch using the freshest ingredients available. From locally sourced dairy to handpicked fruits, Kelly’s spares no expense in ensuring that every scoop is the best it can be.

The attention to detail is evident in every bite. The creaminess of their ice cream is a testament to the high butterfat content and the slow-churn process, which results in a denser, more flavorful product. It’s a difference you can taste and one that keeps customers coming back for more.

Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream is a cornerstone of the community. Kelly and Scott are dedicated to giving back and supporting local causes. From hosting fundraisers to partnering with local schools, Kelly’s is deeply invested in the well-being of Orlando. Their commitment to community extends to their employees as well. Kelly’s fosters a supportive and inclusive work environment where everyone is treated like family. This positive atmosphere translates to exceptional customer service, making every visit to Kelly’s a memorable experience.

Part of what makes Kelly’s so beloved is the fun, welcoming atmosphere they’ve created. The shop itself is a whimsical, pastel-colored wonderland that invites you to relax and enjoy your treat. With charming decor and plenty of seating, it’s the perfect spot for a family outing, a date night, or just a solo indulgence.

And let’s not forget the seasonal flavors and special events. Kelly’s is always coming up with new and exciting flavors to celebrate holidays and special occasions. Whether it’s a pumpkin spice creation for fall or a peppermint delight for the holidays, there’s always something new to try.

It’s no surprise that Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream has garnered numerous awards and accolades over the years. In addition to topping the recent readers’ poll, Kelly’s has been recognized by several local publications as the best ice cream shop in Orlando. Their commitment to quality and community has earned them a loyal following and widespread acclaim.

In addition to their brick-and-mortar shops, Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream also has an ice cream truck that brings their delicious creations to events and neighborhoods throughout Orlando. The truck is a hit at parties, corporate events, and festivals, spreading the joy of Kelly’s one scoop at a time.

For those looking to take their ice cream experience to the next level, Kelly’s offers an array of sundae options that are sure to impress. From build-your-own sundaes with a plethora of toppings to their signature creations, there’s no shortage of delicious possibilities. One of the standout sundaes is the “S’mores Galore.” This indulgent treat features creamy chocolate ice cream, graham cracker crumbs, marshmallow fluff, and a generous drizzle of chocolate sauce. It’s like a campfire treat in a bowl.

Another favorite is the “Fruity Pebbles Delight,” a colorful and playful sundae that combines vanilla ice cream with a crunchy Fruity Pebbles topping and a rainbow of sprinkles. It’s a nostalgic treat that’s sure to bring a smile to your face.

As Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream continues to grow and evolve, one thing remains constant: their dedication to providing the best ice cream experience possible. With new flavors always in development and a commitment to quality that never wavers, the future looks incredibly sweet for Kelly’s and their fans.

So, the next time you’re in need of a sweet treat, head on over to Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream. Grab a scoop (or two, or three), sit back, and savor the deliciousness. 

READ MORE: The 5 best water parks in Florida